How far did general haig deserve
‘command and morale’, my latest book, appeared last week for a long time i’ve been thinking of bringing together some of the articles and book chapters i’ve published over the years. Not because the jews did not deserve a homeland but because in order to establish one they stole large chunks of someone else’s country germany should have given up a province for the jewish people related articles one-minute read us navy on alert as iran threatens to block gulf oil route one-minute read. Within their lifetimes few men are given or deserve that appellation general haig is a hero of world war one because after the war ended, these can therefore be reliably judged, however, the fact that haig did not originally destroy his diary meant that this wife, lady haig, re-typed his diary for him this could mean that she was bias.
We will write a custom essay sample on the first world war – field marshall haig: the butcher of the somme specifically for you for only $1638 $139/page order now lloyd-george also says that ‘i expressed my doubts to general haig’ about this strategy however, how far did general haig deserve to be known as butcher of. How far does general haig deserve to be known as ‘the butcher of the somme’ by the battle of the somme in 1916 the war had been in a huge stalemate for 18 months that didn’t look like it was going to be broken any time soon trenches had been dug on the western front [. Voices comment british incompetence in world war one has been overestimated it's politicians, not the military, who deserve censure i do want british children to learn and understand what we and others fought for. Was haig the butcher of the somme essaysdoes haig deserve his nickname the butcher of the somme feild marshall haig was appointed commander of the army on 10th of december 1915, he was fifty-four at the time and he had had a very succesful military career haig decided to attack the germans.
06-07-2017 this is my second book by matt haig and, to be honest, it's probably going to be my last everything from his writing style to how to stop time has a good premise tom is one of few people in the world who ages at a far slower pace more flag 73 likes like see review jun 22, 2017 whispering stories rated it it was. He had no idea what a real war is however, many historians now believe that general haig was not entirely to blame for the failure at the somme, and that it was not a military disaster, be called a butcher as he left his men to suffer while he lived in a luxurious castle in butcher of the somme essay far away town this granted the germans a. Cambridge international general certificate of secondary education 6922094632 history (us) 0416/13 paper 1 october/november 2016 2 hours how far does general haig deserve to be remembered as the ‘butcher of the somme’ explain your answer ‘de klerk introduced changes in 1990 because he did not have any.
24-02-2006 it may come as a surprise to some of you to learn that the opposite is true of haig as a soldier and a general, haig did very little calvary fighting - for the vast amount of his early career (pre-1900) he was a staff officer who worked on training methods and organisational techniques, skills which were to be of great use but it. Field marshal douglas haig, 1st earl haig, plans for a iii corps attack at cambrai had been proposed as far back as may haig had informed the war office (5 june) that events have proved the utility of tanks and had initially bonar law asked haig what he would do if he were a german general: haig replied that a german offensive would. How far did the front line move on the western front by /u/elos_ did general haig make a good choice by fighting the battle of the somme by /u/elos_ how serious were the mutinies and morale problem in the french army during wwi how did it start and what was actually going on in those units that did mutiny how did the higher.
Do the commanders of the first world war deserve their reputation as ‘butchers and bunglers’ timeline new situation, old tactics 1914 outbreak of war 1915 1988 john laffins book british butchers and bunglers of the first world war does haig deserve his reputation as ‘the butcher of the somme’ conclusion. How far does source a prove that haig did not care about the lives of his men source a insinuates that haig doesn’t care about the lives of his men because he predicts their will be great losses for great britain without considering the men or their families - how far does source a prove that haig did not care about the lives of his men introduction. 15-10-2010 the thing i've always heard about with haig and by extension most of the generals of that era was that they were put into the very definition of a no-win scenario hamilton doesn't really deserve that - yes, he failed at the dardanelles, i mean redvers buller of the boer wars as a strong candidate for the worst general, he was. 23-04-2013 i am not a revisionist and i believe that haig indeed made far too many mistakes, perhaps i should of put it as 'was haig a donkey general during ww1' sniper, jun 26, 2011 #6 gmiller new member also haig's friend, was highly competent and did not deserve to be sacked) gmiller, jun 26, 2011 #7 travis new.
14-10-2010 who do you think was the worst general of all time hats in the ring for haig and macarthur. How far does general haig deserve to be known as ‘the butcher of the somme’ the battle of the somme was the most costly battle in terms of casualties every in the history of british military. Haig as butcher of the somme - help - posted in teaching requests, ideas and resources: can anyone help on (on my teaching practice) and am really stuck for resources and interesting lessons all the lessons so far have been based on source analysis i was hoping to do a collage type exercise where students sift through.
However, general douglas haig, commander of allied forces at the somme, although haig was severely criticized for the costly battle, his willingness to commit massive amounts of men and resources to the stalemate along the western front did eventually contribute to the collapse of an exhausted germany in 1918 fact check we strive for. 12-02-2018 do ww1 generals deserve their bad reputation forum index ». Of that what haig did was infact what he was supposed to do at the time but in this source there was some anti haig comments such as, the cost of victory was appalling - within this assessment i will be responding to the question ‘does general douglas haig deserve his reputation as the “butcher of the somme” as a plentiful amount of. Strategy in the two world wars seminar notes 2 - the western front 'tactical crisis' 9 pages strategy in the two world wars connect to download get doc strategy in the two world wars seminar notes 2 - the western front 'tactical crisis' download strategy in the two world wars seminar notes 2 - the western a lot of what.